This website cannot be viewed properly using this version of Internet Explorer.

To ensure your security while viewing this site, please use a modern browser such as Chrome or update to a newer version of Internet Explorer.

Download Chrome (Made by Google)
Update Internet Explorer (Made by Microsoft)

A A A
ADA ADA symbol

First Judicial District Court

Tribunal del Primer Distrito Judicial

English Español

Last Updated: 4/12/2018


Judge Francis J. Mathew


Notice Re Motions

In all cases that have been assigned to Judge Mathew, it will be necessary for counsel to follow the "Motions Package" procedure stated in Local Rule 1-306(G):

  • At the expiration of all responsive times, under Rule 1‑007.1 of the Rules of Civil Procedure for the District Courts, the movant shall submit to the court a copy of the motion, response, any reply and a request for hearing . . . in a "package". The submission of the "package" alerts the court that the motion is ripe for decision.

Even if you have previously submitted the Motions Package to another judge, it will be necessary to resubmit it to Judge Mathew if you still need a hearing on a motion. It is insufficient to file a notice of completion of briefing without the Motions Package.  It is insufficient to file a request for hearing and notice of hearing without the Motions Package.  

If no response is filed within the time prescribed by Rule 1-007.1, please follow the procedures specified in Local Rule 1-306(D), and serve a copy of a proposed order to the other side with proof of service and submit a copy of the proposed order to the court with a copy of the motion and a notice that no response has been filed.


Notice Re Expedited Motions

If you seek an expedited hearing, i.e., a hearing before the expiration of the time limits set forth in Rule 1-007.1, please follow the procedures in Rule 1-306(I), including stating in the motion the reason for expedited treatment.


These notices apply to all Civil and Domestic Matters in which a party is represented by counsel.

Instructions for Case Scheduling Conference

Word

Interpreter Scheduling

To avoid delay or the rescheduling of your hearing, you must notify the TCAA at 455-8155 within 5 days of your scheduled hearing that an interpreter is needed.

Weather Delays and Closures

IN THE EVENT OF A TWO-HOUR DELAY DUE TO ADVERSE WEATHER, ALL MATTERS SCHEDULED IN THE DELAY PERIOD WILL BE HEARD ON A TRAILING DOCKET BASIS COMMENCING AT THE CONCLUSION OF THE DELAY PERIOD.  FOR EXAMPLE, IF THE FIRST MATTER ON THE DOCKET IS SCHEDULED AT 8:30 A.M., IT WILL BE HEARD AT 10:00 A.M. AT THE CONCLUSION OF A TWO-HOUR DELAY PERIOD AND ALL MATTERS WILL BE HEARD ON A TRAILING DOCKET, BUT NO EARLIER THAN THEIR SCHEDULED HEARING TIME.  IF THE COURT IS CLOSED ON THE DAY YOU HAVE A SCHEDULED HEARING, YOUR HEARING WILL BE RESCHEDULED AND NOTICED BY THE COURT.

 

04/16/2018

8:00 AM

Judge Francis J. Mathew General Session

 

 

9:00 AM

 D-101-CV-2016-02928

 John Elling

  v.

Kurt Young, et. al.

 

 NON JURY TRIAL

 Contract/Debt & Money Due

 

 

 Comment:  Day 1 of 1

Plaintiff

Elling, John        

Atty: Barkley, Jamison        

Defendant

Premiere, Inc.; Young, Kurt     

Atty: Garcia, Alvin Rey     

         

 

 

 

 

04/17/2018

8:00 AM

Judge Francis J. Mathew General Session

 

 

9:00 AM

 D-101-CV-2018-00362

 In The Matter Of The Name Change of Joaquin Thomas Quintana

 

 NAME CHANGE HEARING

 Name Change

 

 

 Comment: 

Plaintiff

       Quintana, Joaquin Thomas 

Atty:         

Defendant

     

Atty:      

         

 

 

 

 

04/18/2018

8:00 AM

Judge Francis J. Mathew General Session

 

 

9:30 AM

 D-101-CV-2018-01100

 Roseann Gonzales

  v.

Louis Espinosa

 

 TEMPORARY RESTRAINING ORDER HEARING

 Miscellaneous Civil

 

 

 Comment: 

Plaintiff

Gonzales, Roseann        

Atty: Pro Se        

Defendant

Espinosa, Louis     

Atty:      

         

 

 

10:00 AM

 D-101-CV-2017-03575

 VISTA LINDA APARTMENTS

  v.

Toysonya Preasha

 

 NON JURY TRIAL

 Civil Appeals - Defendant Appellant

 

 

 Comment:  Completion of Trial de Novo

Plaintiff

    VISTA LINDA APARTMENTS    

Atty:      Banner, Thomas William   

Defendant

   Preasha, Toysonya  

Atty:    Merwald, Kate  

         

 

 

1:15 PM

 D-101-CV-2018-00834

 In The Matter Of The Name Change of Reyna Lucilla Sanchez

 

 NAME CHANGE HEARING

 Name Change

 

 

 Comment: 

Plaintiff

       Sanchez, Reyna Lucilla 

Atty:         

Defendant

     

Atty:      

         

 

 

1:15 PM

 D-101-CV-2018-00870

 In The Matter Of The Name Change of Robert Rodriguez

 

 NAME CHANGE HEARING

 Name Change

 

 

 Comment: 

Plaintiff

       Rodriguez, Robert 

Atty:         

Defendant

     

Atty:      

         

 

 

1:15 PM

 D-101-CV-2018-00838

 In The Matter Of The Name Change of Mary Priscilla Anaya

 

 NAME CHANGE HEARING

 Name Change

 

 

 Comment: 

Plaintiff

       Anaya, Mary Priscilla 

Atty:         

Defendant

     

Atty:      

         

 

 

1:30 PM

 D-101-CV-2017-01464

 Lee Hunt, et. al.,

  v.

Eduardo Contreras, Jr., et. al.

 

 HEARING

 Tort

 

 

 Comment:

Plaintiff

Hunt, Lee; Vargas, Maria        Rogelio Morales Bravo, Jesus

Atty: Lauer, Alisa Cook; Valdez, Suzanna R        

Defendant

Braun, Jerry; Contreras, Eduardo, Jr.; Tuls Cattle Company III LLC; Tuls Cattle Company IV LLC     

Atty: Zangara, Taylor Caroline; Cuff, Tyler M.     

         

 

 

2:00 PM

 D-101-CV-2017-01895

 Laurie Anne Martinez vs. Michael R Allen

 

 SCHEDULING CONFERENCE

 Other

 

 

 Comment:  [SF Non-Jury]

Plaintiff

Martinez, Laurie Anne        Martinez, Joe J.

Atty: Mermelstein, Mark        

Defendant

      Allen, Michael R

Atty:      

         

 

 

2:00 PM

 D-101-CV-2017-02479

 Allstate Fire and Casualty Insurance Company

  v.

Jeremy Stricklin

 

 SCHEDULING CONFERENCE

 Tort Auto

 

 

 Comment:  [SF Jury]

Plaintiff

Allstate Fire and Casualty Insurance Company        

Atty: Barnes, Sarah L. Maestas        

Defendant

Stricklin, Jeremy     

Atty: Komer, Mark E.     

         

 

 

2:00 PM

 D-101-CV-2016-02941

 A-Quality Auto Sales, Inc., et. al.,

  v.

R N S Auto Services, LLC, et. al.

 

 SCHEDULING CONFERENCE

 Other

 

 

 Comment: 

Plaintiff

A-Quality Auto Sales, Inc.; Richesin, Felicia; Richesin, Shawn        

Atty: Sapien, Phillip G.; Romero, Geoffrey R.        

Defendant

Federated  Mutual Insurance Company; Herrera, Matt; Interinsurance Exchange of the Auomobile Club; Kota, Mike; Montoya, Reina; Montoya, Sam; Ortega, Janet; Ortega, Shane; R N S Auto Services, LLC; Travelers Casualty Insurance Company of America     

Atty: Vigil, Charles J.; Sapien, Phillip G.; Unruh, Minal P.; Holmen, Luke     

         

 

 

2:45 PM

  

 

 

 

 

 STATUS HEARING/ CONFERENCE

 

 

 

Comment: 

Petitioner:

 

Atty:  Pro Se       

Respondent:

 

Atty:     

 

           

 

 

3:00 PM

  

 

 

 

 

 STATUS HEARING/ CONFERENCE

 

 

 

Comment: 

Petitioner:

 

Atty:  Kegel, Margaret       

Respondent:

 

Atty:     

 

           

 

 

3:15 PM

  

 

 

 

 

 STATUS HEARING/ CONFERENCE

 

 

 

Comment: 

Petitioner:

 

Atty:  Cox, Johanna C.       

Respondent:

 

Atty:     

 

           

 

 

3:30 PM

  

 

 

 

 

 STATUS HEARING/ CONFERENCE

 

 

 

Comment: 

Petitioner:

 

Atty:  Bruso, Peter L.       

Respondent:

 

Atty:     

 

           

 

 

 

 

04/24/2018

8:00 AM

Judge Francis J. Mathew General Session

 

 

9:30 AM

 D-101-CV-2016-02239

 Arlena Jackson

  v.

The City of Santa Fe, et. al.

 

 MOTION HEARING

 Tort

 

 

 Comment:  Plaintiff's Motion to Compel Video Surveillance  //  Plaintiff's Motion to Exclude Defendant Santa Fe Toyota's Expert Witness, Nelson Welch

Plaintiff

Jackson, Arlena        

Atty: Marshall, Stephen R.        

Defendant

RFJ Auto T-Properties LLC; Santa Fe-T LLC; The City of Santa Fe; The Santa Fe City Police Department     

Atty: Gould, Donald W, Iii; Hatcher, Scott P.     

         

 

 

1:15 PM

 D-101-CV-2016-01299

 Tyler Snyder, et. al.,

  v.

Leslie Dugan

 

 MOTION HEARING

 Tort

 

 

 Comment:  Motion to Compel Defendant to  Answer Plaintiffs' Interrogatory No.15

Plaintiff

Rosingana, Jamie; Snyder, Tyler        

Atty: Ferlic, Katherine M.        

Defendant

Dugan, Leslie     

Atty: Hatcher, Scott P.     

         

 

 

 

 

04/25/2018

8:00 AM

Judge Francis J. Mathew General Session

 

 

10:00 AM

 D-101-CV-2016-01904

 Malarie Trujillo, et. al.,

  v.

Sparton Technology Inc, et. al.

 

 MOTION HEARING

 Tort

 

 

 Comment:  Plaintiffs' Expedited Motion to Strike the Expert Testimony of Defense Expert Brent Kerger  //  Defendants' Motion for Expedited Partial Reconsideration of Denial of Genetic Testing of Agnes, Steven, and Malarie Trujillo

Plaintiff

Trujillo, Agnes; Trujillo, Malarie; Trujillo, Steven        

Atty: Ulrich, Susan        

Defendant

Sparton Corporation; Sparton Technology Inc     

Atty: Covington, Jenny A     

         

 

 

1:30 PM

 D-117-CV-2016-00220

 Sasha J Alire

  v.

Presbyterian Healthcare Services

 

 MOTION HEARING

 Tort Malpractice, Product Liability

 

 

 Comment:  Presbyterian Healthcare Services' Motion in Limine to Exclude Cumulative Expert Witness Testimony and to Limit Plaintiff's Experts to their Opinions Disclosed in Discovery  //  Plaintiff's Motion in Limine to Exclude Reference to Sasha Alire's Prior Drug Use  //  Presbyterian Healthcare Services' Motion in Limine to Exclude Evidence of Other Lawsuits against Defendants   //  Presbyterian Healthcare Services' Omnibus Motion in Limine  //  Presbyterian Healthcare Services' Motion in Limine to Exclude References to Never Events 

Plaintiff

Alire, Sasha J        

Atty: Ferguson, William S.        

Defendant

Presbyterian Healthcare Services     

Atty: Coronel, Patrick A.     

         

 

 

 

 

 

04/26/2018

8:00 AM

Judge Francis J. Mathew General Session

 

 

9:00 AM

 D-101-CV-2017-01314

 Lee Hunt

  v.

The Rio at Rust Centre LLC, et. al.

 

 MOTION HEARING

 Tort

 

 

 Comment:  Defendant The Rio at Cabezon's Motion to Compel Arbitration [Evidentiary Hearing]  //  Plaintiff's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment on the Issue of RCZ Management, LLC and OnPointe Business Services, LLC's Affirmative Defenses Regarding Arbitration

Plaintiff

Hunt, Lee        

Atty: Love, Kathleen J.        

Defendant

IPC Healthcare Inc; IPC Hospitalists Of New Mexico Inc.; OnPointe Business Services; RCZ Management LLC; The Rio at Rust Centre LLC     

Atty: Martin, Jeremy Ian; Slattery, William P.; Hernandez, Michelle A.     

         

 

 

 

 

04/27/2018

8:00 AM

Judge Francis J. Mathew General Session

 

 

9:00 AM

 D-101-CV-2016-02749

 ANNABELL ESPINOZA

  v.

State of New Mexico Taxation and Revenue Department

 

 LICENSE RESTORATION HEARING

 License Revocation Appeal - Defendant Appellant

 

 

 Comment:  Merits

Plaintiff

    ESPINOZA, ANNABELL    

Atty:      Pro Se   

Defendant

   State of New Mexico Taxation and Revenue Department  

Atty:      

         

 

 

9:30 AM

 D-101-CV-2018-00775

 In The Matter Of The Name Change of Andreita Fabia Ruby Romero

 

 NAME CHANGE HEARING

 Name Change

 

 

 Comment: 

Plaintiff

       Romero, Andreita Fabia Ruby 

Atty:         

Defendant

     

Atty:       

         

 

 

9:30 AM

 D-101-CV-2018-01012

 In The Matter Of The Name Change of Eric Leonardo Martinez

 

 NAME CHANGE HEARING

 Name Change

 

 

 Comment: 

Plaintiff

       Martinez, Eric Leonardo 

Atty:         

Defendant

     

Atty:      

         

 

 

9:30 AM

 D-101-CV-2018-00952

 In The Matter Of The Name Change of Craig Albert Mechem

 

 NAME CHANGE HEARING

 Name Change

 

 

 Comment: 

Plaintiff

       Mechem, Craig Albert 

Atty:         

Defendant

     

Atty:      

         

 

 

10:00 AM

 D-117-CV-2017-00005

 Robert Chavez

  v.

Tractor Supply Company

 

 SCHEDULING CONFERENCE

 Tort

 

 

 Comment:  [Rio Arriba Jury]

Plaintiff

Chavez, Robert        

Atty: Davis, Ben        

Defendant

Tractor Supply Company     

Atty: Parkhani, Urvashi     

         

 

 

10:00 AM

 D-101-CV-2014-02255

 Beau Musacco

  v.

State of New Mexico Department of Corrections, et. al.

 

 SCHEDULING CONFERENCE

 Tort

 

 

 Comment:  [SF Jury]

Plaintiff

Musacco, Beau        

Atty: Sitterly, Nicholas        

Defendant

Anderson, Katherine; Barger, James; Birch, Kimberly, MD; Boyer, Michelle; Corizon Health, Inc.; De La Torre, Mike; Fitzgerald, Andrea; Franco, German; Lucero, Alisha; Martinez, Nicole; Ortega, Edward; Pacheco, Joseph; State of New Mexico Department of Corrections; Vigil, Aaron; Vigil, Adam     

Atty: Jarmie, Mark Dawson; Blake, Michelle Marie Lalley; Bullock, Matthew David     

         

 

 

10:00 AM

 D-101-CV-2017-00877

 Mary Walker vs. Kathleen McMahon

 

 SCHEDULING CONFERENCE

 Miscellaneous Civil

 

 

 Comment:  [SF Non-Jury]

Plaintiff

Walker, Mary        

Atty: Sommer, Kurt A.        

Defendant

McMahon, Kathleen     

Atty: Gilbert, Kurt Blaine     

         

 

 

10:00 AM

 D-101-CV-2017-00838

 Pete Romero

  v.

Circle K Stores, Inc, et. al.

 

 SCHEDULING CONFERENCE

 Other

 

 

 Comment:  [SF Jury]

Plaintiff

Romero, Pete        

Atty: Sapien, Phillip G.        

Defendant

Circle K Stores, Inc; Grogan, James; Stannebein, Mark; Wilson, Samuel     

Atty: Eaton, P. Scott     

         

 

 

10:00 AM

 D-101-CV-2017-01871

 Valerie L Barboa

  v.

New Mexico Department of Corrections

 

 SCHEDULING CONFERENCE

 Miscellaneous Civil

 

 

 Comment:  [SF Jury]

Plaintiff

Barboa, Valerie L        

Atty: Alarid, Jason M.        

Defendant

New Mexico Department of Corrections     

Atty: Heitz, Michael R.     

         

 

 

11:00 AM

  

 

 

 

 

 HEARING

 

 

 

Comment: 

Petitioner:

 

Atty:  Pro Se       

Respondent:

 

Atty:     

 

           

 

 

1:15 PM

 D-101-CV-2017-02511

 ALBERT CATANACH

  v.

ELENA BENTON

 

 MOTION HEARING

 Other

 

 

 Comment:  Defendant Elena Benton's Special Motion to Dismiss or for Summary Judgment Pursuant to NMRA 1-012(B)(6), 1-056 and Remedies Pursuant to NMSA Section 38-2-9.1

Plaintiff

CATANACH, ALBERT        

Atty: Glassman, Richard S.        

Defendant

BENTON, ELENA     

Atty: Butler, Timothy Lannon     

         

 

 

2:00 PM

 D-101-CV-2017-00019

 Agua Fria Compound Association Inc

  v.

Dorothy Routt, et. al.

 

 MOTION HEARING

 Contract/Debt & Money Due

 

 

 Comment:  Plaintiff's Motion for Voluntary Dismissal

Plaintiff

Agua Fria Compound Association Inc        

Atty: Grimmer, Christopher M.        

Defendant

Routt, Dorothy; Routt, Spirit; Routt, Spirit     

Atty: Pro Se     

         

 

 

2:15 PM

 D-117-CV-2017-00449

 Bank of America

  v.

Mark M Ericksen, et. al.

 

 MOTION HEARING

 Real Estate

 

 

 Comment:  Motion to Substitute Plaintiff

Plaintiff

Bank of America        

Atty: Weaver, Karen Howden        

Defendant

Ericksen Family Trust; Ericksen, Mark M; The Secretary of Housing and Urban Development     

Atty: Lucero, Manuel     

         

 

 

2:30 PM

 D-101-CV-2014-02541

 Zia Trust, Inc.

  v.

PHC-Las Cruces, Inc.

 

 MOTION HEARING

 Tort

 

 

 Comment:  Defendant PHC-Las Cruces, Inc. d/b/a Memorial Medical Center's Motion for Summary Judgment  //  Defendant Memorial Medical Center's Second Motion to Dismiss with Prejudice for Failure to Prosecute

Plaintiff

Zia Trust, Inc.        

Atty: Romero, Julio C.        

Defendant

PHC-Las Cruces, Inc.     

Atty: Dekleva, Michael J.     

         

 

 

3:00 PM

 D-101-CV-2015-02565

 DAVID SENA, et. al.,

  v.

THE WESTERN GROUP, LC, et. al.

 

 HEARING

 Tort

 

 

 Comment: 

Plaintiff

Coburn, Laura; SENA, DAVID        Coburn, Jesse T, III

Atty: Komer, Mark E.; Osborne, John Edwards        

Defendant

SOUTHWESTERN RAILROAD, INC.; Southwestern Shortline Railroad Company; THE WESTERN GROUP, LC     

Atty: Crooks, Julia Elizabeth     

         

 

 

 

 

04/30/2018

8:30 AM

Judge Francis J. Mathew General Session

 

 

8:30 AM

 D-117-CV-2016-00220

 Sasha J Alire

  v.

Presbyterian Healthcare Services

 

 JURY SELECTION and TRIAL

 Tort Malpractice, Product Liability

 

 

 Comment:  [Day 1 of 4]

Plaintiff

Alire, Sasha J        

Atty: Ferguson, William S.        

Defendant

Presbyterian Healthcare Services     

Atty: Coronel, Patrick A.     

         

 

 

 

 

05/01/2018

8:00 AM

Judge Francis J. Mathew General Session

 

 

8:30 AM

 D-117-CV-2016-00220

 Sasha J Alire

  v.

Presbyterian Healthcare Services

 

 JURY TRIAL

 Tort Malpractice, Product Liability

 

 

 Comment:  [Day 2 of 4]

Plaintiff

Alire, Sasha J        

Atty: Ferguson, William S.        

Defendant

Presbyterian Healthcare Services     

Atty: Coronel, Patrick A.     

         

 

 

 

 

05/02/2018

8:00 AM

Judge Francis J. Mathew General Session

 

 

8:30 AM

 D-117-CV-2016-00220

 Sasha J Alire

  v.

Presbyterian Healthcare Services

 

 JURY TRIAL

 Tort Malpractice, Product Liability

 

 

 Comment:  [Day 3 of 4]

Plaintiff

Alire, Sasha J        

Atty: Ferguson, William S.        

Defendant

Presbyterian Healthcare Services     

Atty: Coronel, Patrick A.     

         

 

 

 

 

05/03/2018

8:00 AM

Judge Francis J. Mathew General Session

 

 

8:30 AM

 D-117-CV-2016-00220

 Sasha J Alire

  v.

Presbyterian Healthcare Services

 

 JURY TRIAL

 Tort Malpractice, Product Liability

 

 

 Comment:  [Day 4 of 4]

Plaintiff

Alire, Sasha J        

Atty: Ferguson, William S.        

Defendant

Presbyterian Healthcare Services     

Atty: Coronel, Patrick A.