This website cannot be viewed properly using this version of Internet Explorer.

To ensure your security while viewing this site, please use a modern browser such as Chrome or update to a newer version of Internet Explorer.

Download Chrome (Made by Google)
Update Internet Explorer (Made by Microsoft)

A A A

First Judicial District Court

Tribunal del Primer Distrito Judicial

English Español

Judge Francis J. Mathew

Last Updated:  10/16/2020


Remote Access (Effective for all hearings set on or after August 17, 2020) See Fifth Amended Notice Below

Appearing by video: meet.google.com/pbm-prjx-suz

Appearing by telephone: Phone number: 1-(401)-594-2884 and PIN: ‪457 389 237#.


JURY TRIALS NOTICE - Dated 6/2/2020

On May 28, 2020, the New Mexico Supreme Court issued its Order No. 20-8500-020 concerning the lifting of its suspension of civil and criminal jury trials.  Under the terms of the Order, New Mexico Courts may recommence jury trials under certain conditions, including maintaining social distancing of no less than six (6) feet of separation, limiting room occupancy to fifteen (15) people, including judges and court staff, except with permission, and requiring all persons in and around the courthouse to wear masks at all times.

For the 1st Judicial District Court to comply with Order No. 20-8500-20, it has been left with only two (2) spaces that can accommodate jury trials requiring a panel of twelve (12) jurors plus two (2) alternates.  One space is the Ceremonial Courtroom, currently assigned to Judge Biedscheid, and the other space is the Jury Assembly Room where our juries have been chosen and assembled throughout the trial dockets.  These two (2) spaces will necessarily have to be shared by eight (8) judges.  Each space will be shared by four (4) judges. 

At this time, it appears that six (6) person juries may go forward in the standard courtrooms with the jury deliberation rooms being utilized under the current space and social distancing limitations.

The Ceremonial Courtroom must be used for judges with criminal dockets due to security requirements.  The Jury Assembly Room will be shared by four (4) civil judges.  This Division, Division No. 1, has been assigned to the Jury Assembly Room for the purpose of conducting jury trials. 

The Jury Assembly Room requires certain modifications including mobile monitors for evidence displays and will not have certain podium electronic capabilities.  Both spaces require the use of adjoining courtrooms for jury deliberations, resulting in the loss of these courtrooms for hearings and bench trials during jury trials. 

To accommodate the space sharing by four (4) judges, the Court has been required to suspend the current assigned jury docket schedules.  In  an attempt to provide each judge with as much time as possible in the available spaces, the Court is contemplating assigning each judge a two (2) week jury docket on a rotating schedule.  The Santa Fe civil judges’ dockets will typically commence on Mondays.

Juries in the 1st Judicial District will no longer be chosen for the entire scheduled docket on the first day of the judge’s docket.  Smaller jury panels will be called so that social distancing may be maintained and room occupancy limitations complied with. This will likely mean that multiple panels will need to be called and staggered throughout the day and that individual voir dire of potential jurors will be more limited. It could and probably will mean the use of an entire day to assemble one (1) twelve (12) person jury with alternates. Juries for trials will be chosen on the first day of the re-assigned trial date(s), and trials will commence as soon as the jury has been chosen. 

Trials in this Division will continue to be scheduled on a trailing docket basis.  So that as many jury trials as possible may be conducted, this Division, Division 1, will be typically limiting trial times to five (5) days, including jury selection.   

 In this Division, Plaintiffs will be allowed 60% of the trial time for their case and defendants without counterclaims will receive 40% of the trial time; provided that cases with counterclaims will receive a 50/50 time split.  All trial time will be calculated strictly on a percentage of the total trial time, including opening statements and closing arguments, without regard to actual time spent on direct or cross-examination. Cross-examination will be limited to 75% of the time used in direct examination.  Reasonably anticipated evidentiary objections will necessarily be required to be resolved before trial.  Opening statements and closing arguments will be limited in time.

Until the Courts can safely conduct twelve (12) person jury trials in our standard courtrooms with our standard deliberation rooms, there will be certain cases that will not be able to have a trial conducted due to the limited space and the number of parties and attorneys involved.  The Court is researching potential alternatives for these cases.  Unfortunately, the Court cannot predict when this situation may change or when viable alternatives may be found.

We are all cognizant that this is a temporary situation, but it is a situation without a predictable end.  It may last more than a year without any way to predict when we may be allowed to return to operations similar to those in place before the current public health emergency.


FIFTH AMENDED NOTICE

Dated July 20, 2020

(Effective For All Hearings Set On Or After August 17, 2020)

Until the current operating guidelines for the New Mexico Courts which have been put in place concerning the Coronavirus are modified, parties and attorneys are required to appear for all hearings telephonically or through video conferencing. Parties and attorneys are required to appear telephonically or through video conferencing for any hearing, including pretrial conferences, by providing notice to the Court at its sfeddiv1proposedtxt@nmcourts.gov email address at least one (1) business day prior to any such hearing and:

Appearing by video through the following computer link connection: meet.google.com/pbm-prjx-suz; or

Appearing by dialing the following phone number and using the pin number when prompted: Phone number:1-(401)-594-2884 and PIN: ‪457 389 237#.

This is not a private hearing room and other hearings may be in progress when you join, therefore, you are required to join muted or immediately mute your phone/microphone upon joining and not speak until the Court calls you or announces your case.

There is no charge to participants for this service. 

Cell phones, speaker phones and microphones can cause background interference and a garbled presentation, so you are requested to use telephone handsets when appearing telephonically, or to mute your phones/microphones when not speaking.

Although the proceeding may be remote, all rules governing demeanor, dress and recording remain in effect.  The official record of any hearing is the record taken or recorded by the Court’s Reporter or Monitor and must be used for all purposes.

This Notice is effective for all hearings scheduled on or after August 17, 2020, until further notice by the Court.

In person courtroom attendance by attorneys and parties shall only be allowed on an emergency basis upon motion and order of the Court.  Spectators, media and visitors are not allowed in the courtroom, but may attend through the same media available to parties and attorneys in accordance with applicable New Mexico Supreme Court Orders and Rules. Spectators, media and visitors are not required to notify the Court of their attendance prior to any video or telephonic hearing. 

Please monitor the Court’s website for notices concerning current courtroom procedures and guidelines.


SUMMARY JURY TRIALS

Voluntary (all parties must agree by written stipulation filed no less than forty-five days prior to trial)

Binding

Nonbinding

Six (6) person jury

One (1) alternate

Three (3) peremptory challenges per side

Jurors may sit for more than one (1) trial

Rule 1-038 applies

Selected at regular jury selection for docket first

Void Dire

i. Judge regular

ii. Each side limited to fifteen (15) minutes

Trial – One (1) day

Openings - fifteen (15) minutes

Closings - fifteen (15) minutes

Presentations – two (2) hours per side

i. Cross-examination – seventy-five percent (75%) of time of direct examination of each witness

ii. Example - Direct examination is 1 hour; cross-examination is limited to 45 minutes with 15 minutes remaining for direct and cross-examination of another witness within presentation time

Experts – Evidence limited to reports, not to exceed ten (10) pages, not including expert’s CV.

Pretrial Procedures

Standard pretrial procedures, including the filing of the pre-trial orders no later than the date of the Pre-trial Conference and no extensions to be granted.

Rules of Evidence apply

i. Objections to authenticity and admissibility of exhibits must be made and ruled upon before trial with all such objections made no later than the date of the Pre-trial Conference and responses to objections made two (2) days after objections; no reply permitted

ii. Designations and objections to depositions ruled upon before trial

iii. Motions In Limine made no later than the date of the Pre-trial Conference ruled upon at same time as exhibits, including objections to expert qualification and testimony

iv. Jury Instructions in accordance with standard scheduling orders, but jury instruction conference held in the week before jury selection

Post trial matters

Nonbinding verdict

i. Priority setting on next docket as regular setting without summary jury limitations and new pre-trial order

Deadlocked jury

i. Priority setting on next docket as regular setting without summary jury limitations and new pre-trial order

Binding verdict

Judgment entered

d.  Costs and fees, not awarded

Jury dockets

Four (4) days following jury selection reserved for Summary Jury Trials

Remaining docket- not Summary Jury Trials

i. Trials limited to five (5) days, if more than one (1) trial remaining at Pre-trial Conference

ii. Presentations divided sixty percent (60%) – Plaintiff and forty percent (40%) Defendant

iii. Rules of Procedure and Evidence apply


Notice Re Motions

In all cases that have been assigned to Judge Mathew, it will be necessary for counsel to follow the "Motions Package" procedure stated in Local Rule 1-306(G):

  • At the expiration of all responsive times, under Rule 1‑007.1 of the Rules of Civil Procedure for the District Courts, the movant shall submit to the court a copy of the motion, response, any reply and a request for hearing . . . in a "package". The submission of the "package" alerts the court that the motion is ripe for decision.

Even if you have previously submitted the Motions Package to another judge, it will be necessary to resubmit it to Judge Mathew if you still need a hearing on a motion. It is insufficient to file a notice of completion of briefing without the Motions Package.  It is insufficient to file a request for hearing and notice of hearing without the Motions Package.  

If no response is filed within the time prescribed by Rule 1-007.1, please follow the procedures specified in Local Rule 1-306(D), and serve a copy of a proposed order to the other side with proof of service and submit a copy of the proposed order to the court with a copy of the motion and a notice that no response has been filed.


Notice Re Expedited Motions

If you seek an expedited hearing, i.e., a hearing before the expiration of the time limits set forth in Rule 1-007.1, please follow the procedures in Rule 1-306(I), including stating in the motion the reason for expedited treatment.

These notices apply to all Civil and Domestic Matters in which a party is represented by counsel.

Instructions for Case Scheduling Conference

Word


Interpreter Scheduling

To avoid delay or the rescheduling of your hearing, you must notify the TCAA at 455-8155 within 5 days of your scheduled hearing that an interpreter is needed.


Weather Delays and Closures

IN THE EVENT OF A TWO-HOUR DELAY DUE TO ADVERSE WEATHER, ALL MATTERS SCHEDULED IN THE DELAY PERIOD WILL BE HEARD ON A TRAILING DOCKET BASIS COMMENCING AT THE CONCLUSION OF THE DELAY PERIOD.  FOR EXAMPLE, IF THE FIRST MATTER ON THE DOCKET IS SCHEDULED AT 8:30 A.M., IT WILL BE HEARD AT 10:00 A.M. AT THE CONCLUSION OF A TWO-HOUR DELAY PERIOD AND ALL MATTERS WILL BE HEARD ON A TRAILING DOCKET, BUT NO EARLIER THAN THEIR SCHEDULED HEARING TIME.  IF THE COURT IS CLOSED ON THE DAY YOU HAVE A SCHEDULED HEARING, YOUR HEARING WILL BE RESCHEDULED AND NOTICED BY THE COURT.


10/19/2020

8:00 AM

Judge Francis J. Mathew General Session

 

9:00 AM

 D-101-CV-2019-02386

 Xray Associates of New Mexico PC

  v.

Michael Rueckhaus, et. al.

 MOTION HEARING

 Other

 Comment:  X-Ray Associates of New Mexico, P.C.'s Motion to Exclude Anderson Defendants' Expert Witness J. Robert Hunter  //  Defendant Russell Toal's Motion for Declaratory Judgment on the Pleadings  //  Defendants, Michael Rueckhaus and the New Mexico Medical Review Commission's Motion for Summary Judgment  //  X-Ray Associates of New Mexico, P.C.'s Motion for Summary Judgment  //  Defendants Andersons' Motion for Summary Judgment

Plaintiff

Xray Associates of New Mexico PC        

Atty: Slattery, William P.        

Defendant

Anderson, Bruce; Anderson, Lanell; Franchini, John G; New Mexico Medical Review Commission; Rueckhaus, Michael     

Atty: Curtis, Lisa K.; Walker, R. Alfred; Mann, Nathan H.     

 

1:15 PM

  

  In The Matter Of Lawana L Frith

D-101-PB-2011-00076

 MOTION HEARING

  Probate Informal, Will

Comment:  Co-Personal Representative Nancy Firth's Motion for Disbursement

Petitioner:

  FELKER, RANDOLPH B FELKER, RANDOLPH B      

Atty:  Pro Se; Moore, Deborah L.       

Respondent:

    

Atty:     

 

1:45 PM

 HEARING

Comment:

Petitioner:

Atty:  Fenoglio, Ella Joan  

Respondent:

Atty:   

 

10/20/2020

8:00 AM

Judge Francis J. Mathew General Session

 

9:00 AM

 D-101-CV-2019-00746

 Marcos A Garcia

  v.

City of Santa Fe, et. al.

 MOTION HEARING

 Civil Violations, Statutes, Ordinances

 Comment:  City Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment

Plaintiff

Garcia, Marcos A        

Atty: Raphaelson, Sheri A.        

Defendant

CITY OF SANTA FE; Litzenberg, Erik     

Atty: Robles, Luis E.     

 

9:30 AM

 D-101-CV-2019-00893

 Lauren Cochran, et. al.,

  v.

Presbyterian Healthare Services a NM Corp DBA Presbyterian Rust Medical Center, et. al.

 MOTION HEARING

 Tort Malpractice, Product Liability

 Comment:  Plaintiffs' Motion to Compel Adequate Expert Disclosures from Defendants  //  Plaintiffs' Motion to Strike Untimely Disclosed Experts

Plaintiff

Cochran, Lauren; Willis, Talmage Earl, IV        

Atty: Mcginn, Randi; Curry, Katie        

Defendant

Etsitty, Edison V, MD; Garcia, Victoria, MD; Henningsen-Schwarz CNM, Kristin S; Presbyterian Healthare Services a NM Corp DBA Presbyterian Rust Medical Center     

Atty: Behm, Mary Moran     

 

10:00 AM

 D-101-CV-2017-00581

 Robert Mason

  v.

Juan R Edwards

 HEARING

 Contract/Debt & Money Due

 Comment:  Attorney's Fees and Costs

Plaintiff

Mason, Robert        

Atty: Walsh, Joseph P.        

Defendant

Edwards, Juan R     

Atty:      

 

10:30 AM

 D-101-CV-2018-02985

 In The Matter Of Severo Ortega

 MOTION HEARING

 Wrongful Death Personal Representative

 Comment:  Defendant Presbyterian Healthcare Services' Motion for Summary Judgment on Vicarious Liability

Plaintiff

      Trujillo, Liana Trujillo, Liana 

Atty:         Trujillo, Liana

Defendant

Doe, Jane; Doe, John; Lakshmi-Narayanan, Salvadeeswa, MD; Montesinos, James J, MD; Montoya, Patrick R, MD; PRESBYTERIAN HEALTHCARE SERVICES INC; Rivera, Eugenio, MD; Ryan, William M, MD; Sherman, Victor, MD; Southam, Samuel L, MD; Sugar, Melissa, MD; Unknown Corporations A thru Z     

Atty: Saiz, Brenda M.     

 

1:15 PM

 D-101-CV-2017-00898

 Wilmer Alexander Gaytan, et. al.,

  v.

Shohko Cafe

 STATUS CONFERENCE

 Civil Violations, Statutes, Ordinances

 Comment: 

Plaintiff

Gaytan, Wilmer Alexander; Matzir, Victor; Ramirez, Luis        

Atty: Quinones, Carlos M.        

Defendant

Shohko Cafe     

Atty: Howell, Trent Atkins     

 

10/21/2020

8:00 AM

Judge Francis J. Mathew General Session

 

10:00 AM

 D-101-CV-2020-01917

 Maurice Bonal

  v.

David Ahern Seronde

 TEMPORARY RESTRAINING ORDER HEARING

 Miscellaneous Civil

 Comment: 

Plaintiff

BONAL, MAURICE        

Atty: Pro Se        

Defendant

Ahern Seronde, David     

Atty:      

 

10:30 AM

 D-101-CV-2020-02146

 Uniprop-Sierra Vista Limited Partnership

  v.

Vitalia Candelaria

 HEARING

 Real Estate

 Comment:  Notice of Trial on Petition for Termination of Tenancy

Plaintiff

Uniprop-Sierra Vista Limited Partnership        

Atty: Chavez, James A.        

Defendant

Candelaria, Vitalia     

Atty:      

 

1:15 PM

 D-117-CV-2019-00136

 Kelley Thurston, et. al.,

  v.

Clarence Garcia, et. al.

 MOTION HEARING

 Tort

 Comment:  Defendant Familyworks' Motion for Sanctions against Plaintiff's Counsel Sean Claggett and Motion for Protective Order  //  Plaintiff's Motion to Use Custom UJI Regarding the Garcia's Invocation of Fifth Amendment //  Plaintiff's Motion to Limit Number of Peremptory

Strikes for Aligned Defendants  //  Garcia Defendants' Emergency Motion to Cure Special Jury Questionnaires  //  Garcia Defendants' Supplemental Brief in Support of Motion in Limine Regarding Hearsay

Plaintiff

Inman, Shasta N.; Thurston, Kelley        

Atty: Conaway, Joshua K.        

Defendant

Acadia Healthcare Company Inc; Familyworks Inc; Garcia, Clarence; Garcia, Debbie; Jacobs, Joey; Youth and Family Centered Services of New Mexico Inc     

Atty: Clement, Ryan Lee; Shover, Leah R.; Garcia, Bryan Christopher; Baker, Mark Travis     

 

 

10/22/2020

8:00 AM

Judge Francis J. Mathew General Session

 

10:45 AM

 D-117-CV-2019-00590

 TD Bank USA NA

  v.

Glendalyn M Baca

 MOTION HEARING

 Contract/Debt & Money Due

 Comment:  Motion for Default Judgment

Plaintiff

TD Bank USA NA        

Atty: Mowrer, F. M.        

Defendant

Baca, Glendalyn M     

Atty:      

 

11:00 AM

  

 HEARING

Petitioner:

Atty:  Turner, Patricia J.       

Respondent:

Atty:     

 

1:15 PM

 D-101-CV-2020-02091

 In The Matter Of The Name Change of Debbi Sue Bybee

 NAME CHANGE HEARING

 Name Change

 Comment: 

Plaintiff

       Bybee, Debbi Sue 

Atty:         

Defendant

     

Atty:      

 

1:30 PM

  

  In The Matter Of Celeste M Romero

D-101-PB-2019-00170

 HEARING

  Probate Formal, Will

Comment:  Petition for Order of Complete Settlement of Estate by Special Administrator

Petitioner:

  Christensen Consulting LLC Christensen Consulting LLC      

Atty:  Cullen, Christopher Cullen, Christopher      

Respondent:

    

Atty:     

 

1:45 PM

  

 STATUS CONFERENCE

 

Comment: 

Petitioner:

Atty:  Gallegos, Laurie A.       

Respondent:

Atty:     

 

10/23/2020

8:00 AM

Judge Francis J. Mathew General Session

 

9:00 AM

 D-101-CV-2018-02171

 Peter Wirth, et. al.,

  v.

Cory Thompson, et. al.

 MOTION HEARING

 Tort

 Comment:  Jonathan Owens, M.D. and Las Cruces Physician Practices, LLC's Motion in Limine to Exclude Unfounded Inferences of any Delay in Consultation and Opinion Testimony Elicited through Factually Erroneous Hypotheticals  //  Defendants Stephanie Benson, M.D.'s and Diana Escobedo, M.D.'s Motion in Limine No. 3 to Preclude Improper Lay Witness Testimony  //  Defendants Stephanie Benson, M.D.'s and Diana Escobedo, M.D.'s Motion in Limine No. 2 to Preclude Plaintiffs from Soliciting Improper or Undisclosed Opinions from Experts  //  Jonathan Owens, M.D. and Las Cruces Physician Practices, LLC d/b/a Memorial Ear, Nose & Throat Institute's Motion Regarding Peremptory Strikes and Trial Procedure  //  Defendants Stephanie Benson, M.D.'s and Diana Escobedo, M.D.'s Motion in Limine No. 5 to Prohibit Distortion of Jury Instructions and the Law  //  Defendants Stephanie Benson, M.D.'s and Diana Escobedo, M.D.'s Motion in Limine No. 4 to Preclude the Use of Video Testimony in Opening Statement, Closing Argument, and if Witness also Testifies Live  //  Defendants Stephanie Benson, M.D.’s and Diana Escobedo, M.D.'s Motion in Limine No. 1 to Preclude Evidence of Alleged Wrongdoing that was not a Breach of the Standard of Care or a Cause of Ms. Valencia's Death  //  Jonathan Owens, M.D. and Las Cruces Physician Practices, LLC's Motions in Limine  //  Jonathan Owens, M.D. and Las Cruces Physician Practices, LLC's Motion in Limine to Exclude Cumulative Fact and Expert Testimony  //  Presentment of Order Denying Defendant MMC/MMC Nurses' Motion for Partial Summary Judgment regarding Application of the Medical Malpractice Act to pending Negligence Claims against Defendants Kristina Polanco, RN, Brenda Dailey, RN, Xochitl Graham, RN, and Megan Wilson, RN

Plaintiff

Blanco, Renee; Valencia, Gilbert; Wirth, Peter         

Atty: Cervantes, K. Joseph        

Defendant

Benson, Stephanie, MD; D M D; Daily, Brenda, RN; Escobedo, Diana, MD; Graham, Xochitl, RN; Las Cruces Physician Practices LLC; Lifepoint Health Inc; Memorial Ear Nose and Throat Institute; Ontiveros, Kristy, MD; Owens, Jonathan, MD; PHC Las Cruces Inc; Polanco, Kristina, RN; Reynolds, Lizabeth, MD; Southern New Mexico Dental Group PC; Thompson, Cory; Wilson, Megan, RN     

Atty: Ali, Nora; Maggiore, W. Ann; Kenny, Rebecca Shaw; Parker, Jennifer Lyn; Smith, Kemp; Mann, John Scott; Rogers, Lee M., Jr.; Cash, Paul M; Miller, Kimberly Ann Norvell     

 

 

 

 

 

10/26/2020

8:00 AM

Judge Francis J. Mathew General Session

 

8:30 AM

 D-117-CV-2019-00136

 Kelley Thurston, et. al.,

  v.

Clarence Garcia, et. al.

 JURY SELECTION HEARING

 Tort

 Comment: 

Plaintiff

Inman, Shasta N.; Thurston, Kelley        

Atty: Conaway, Joshua K.        

Defendant

Acadia Healthcare Company Inc; Familyworks Inc; Garcia, Clarence; Garcia, Debbie; Jacobs, Joey; Youth and Family Centered Services of New Mexico Inc     

Atty: Clement, Ryan Lee; Shover, Leah R.; Garcia, Bryan Christopher; Baker, Mark Travis     

 

10/27/2020

8:00 AM

Judge Francis J. Mathew General Session

 

8:30 AM

 D-117-CV-2019-00136

 Kelley Thurston, et. al.,

  v.

Clarence Garcia, et. al.

 JURY TRIAL

 Tort

 Comment: 

Plaintiff

Inman, Shasta N.; Thurston, Kelley        

Atty: Conaway, Joshua K.        

Defendant

Acadia Healthcare Company Inc; Familyworks Inc; Garcia, Clarence; Garcia, Debbie; Jacobs, Joey; Youth and Family Centered Services of New Mexico Inc     

Atty: Clement, Ryan Lee; Shover, Leah R.; Garcia, Bryan Christopher; Baker, Mark Travis     

 

10/28/2020

8:00 AM

Judge Francis J. Mathew General Session

 

8:30 AM

 D-117-CV-2019-00136

 Kelley Thurston, et. al.,

  v.

Clarence Garcia, et. al.

 JURY TRIAL

 Tort

 Comment: 

Plaintiff

Inman, Shasta N.; Thurston, Kelley        

Atty: Conaway, Joshua K.        

Defendant

Acadia Healthcare Company Inc; Familyworks Inc; Garcia, Clarence; Garcia, Debbie; Jacobs, Joey; Youth and Family Centered Services of New Mexico Inc     

Atty: Clement, Ryan Lee; Shover, Leah R.; Garcia, Bryan Christopher; Baker, Mark Travis     

 

10/29/2020

8:00 AM

Judge Francis J. Mathew General Session

 

8:30 AM

 D-117-CV-2019-00136

 Kelley Thurston, et. al.,

  v.

Clarence Garcia, et. al.

 JURY TRIAL

 Tort

 Comment: 

Plaintiff

Inman, Shasta N.; Thurston, Kelley        

Atty: Conaway, Joshua K.        

Defendant

Acadia Healthcare Company Inc; Familyworks Inc; Garcia, Clarence; Garcia, Debbie; Jacobs, Joey; Youth and Family Centered Services of New Mexico Inc     

Atty: Clement, Ryan Lee; Shover, Leah R.; Garcia, Bryan Christopher; Baker, Mark Travis     

 

10/30/2020

8:00 AM

Judge Francis J. Mathew General Session

 

8:30 AM

 D-117-CV-2019-00136

 Kelley Thurston, et. al.,

  v.

Clarence Garcia, et. al.

 JURY TRIAL

 Tort

 Comment: 

Plaintiff

Inman, Shasta N.; Thurston, Kelley        

Atty: Conaway, Joshua K.         

Defendant

Acadia Healthcare Company Inc; Familyworks Inc; Garcia, Clarence; Garcia, Debbie; Jacobs, Joey; Youth and Family Centered Services of New Mexico Inc     

Atty: Clement, Ryan Lee; Shover, Leah R.; Garcia, Bryan Christopher; Baker, Mark Travis     

 

11/02/2020

8:00 AM

Judge Francis J. Mathew General Session

 

8:30 AM

 D-117-CV-2019-00136

 Kelley Thurston, et. al.,

  v.

Clarence Garcia, et. al.

 JURY TRIAL

 Tort

 Comment: 

Plaintiff

Inman, Shasta N.; Thurston, Kelley        

Atty: Conaway, Joshua K.        

Defendant

Acadia Healthcare Company Inc; Familyworks Inc; Garcia, Clarence; Garcia, Debbie; Jacobs, Joey; Youth and Family Centered Services of New Mexico Inc     

Atty: Clement, Ryan Lee; Shover, Leah R.; Garcia, Bryan Christopher; Baker, Mark Travis     

 

11/03/2020

8:00 AM

Judge Francis J. Mathew General Session

 

8:30 AM

 D-117-CV-2019-00136

 Kelley Thurston, et. al.,

  v.

Clarence Garcia, et. al.

 JURY TRIAL

 Tort

 Comment: 

Plaintiff

Inman, Shasta N.; Thurston, Kelley        

Atty: Conaway, Joshua K.        

Defendant

Acadia Healthcare Company Inc; Familyworks Inc; Garcia, Clarence; Garcia, Debbie; Jacobs, Joey; Youth and Family Centered Services of New Mexico Inc     

Atty: Clement, Ryan Lee; Shover, Leah R.; Garcia, Bryan Christopher; Baker, Mark Travis     

 

11/04/2020

8:00 AM

Judge Francis J. Mathew General Session

 

8:30 AM

 D-117-CV-2019-00136

 Kelley Thurston, et. al.,

  v.

Clarence Garcia, et. al.

 JURY TRIAL

 Tort

 Comment: 

Plaintiff

Inman, Shasta N.; Thurston, Kelley        

Atty: Conaway, Joshua K.        

Defendant

Acadia Healthcare Company Inc; Familyworks Inc; Garcia, Clarence; Garcia, Debbie; Jacobs, Joey; Youth and Family Centered Services of New Mexico Inc      

Atty: Clement, Ryan Lee; Shover, Leah R.; Garcia, Bryan Christopher; Baker, Mark Travis     

 

11/05/2020

8:00 AM

Judge Francis J. Mathew General Session

 

8:30 AM

 D-117-CV-2019-00136

 Kelley Thurston, et. al.,

  v.

Clarence Garcia, et. al.

 JURY TRIAL

 Tort

 Comment: 

Plaintiff

Inman, Shasta N.; Thurston, Kelley        

Atty: Conaway, Joshua K.        

Defendant

Acadia Healthcare Company Inc; Familyworks Inc; Garcia, Clarence; Garcia, Debbie; Jacobs, Joey; Youth and Family Centered Services of New Mexico Inc     

Atty: Clement, Ryan Lee; Shover, Leah R.; Garcia, Bryan Christopher; Baker, Mark Travis     

 

11/06/2020

8:00 AM

Judge Francis J. Mathew General Session

 

8:30 AM

 D-117-CV-2019-00136

 Kelley Thurston, et. al.,

  v.

Clarence Garcia, et. al.

 JURY TRIAL

 Tort

 Comment: 

Plaintiff

Inman, Shasta N.; Thurston, Kelley        

Atty: Conaway, Joshua K.        

Defendant

Acadia Healthcare Company Inc; Familyworks Inc; Garcia, Clarence; Garcia, Debbie; Jacobs, Joey; Youth and Family Centered Services of New Mexico Inc     

Atty: Clement, Ryan Lee; Shover, Leah R.; Garcia, Bryan Christopher; Baker, Mark Travis     

 

11/12/2020

8:00 AM

Judge Francis J. Mathew General Session

 

10:00 AM

 D-101-CV-2019-02836

 Joleen Youngers

  v.

Howard Johnson International Inc, et. al.

 MOTION HEARING

 Tort

 Comment:  Defendants' Motion to Stay Proceedings Pending Resolution of Related Criminal Proceedings

Plaintiff

Youngers, Joleen      Youngers, Joleen  

Atty: Ives, Laura Louise Schauer        Youngers, Joleen

Defendant

ABQ 1701 LLC; G6 Hospitality LLC; Howard Johnson International Inc; I-25 Hotel Corporation; Khan, Shariq; Motel 6 Operating LP #140; Tufaro, Jerry; Wyndham Hotels and Resorts LLC     

Atty: Pro Se; Walker, Alex Cameron; Allen, Meena H.     

 

11:15 AM

  

 PRESENTMENT HEARING

Comment:

Petitioner:

Atty:  Baysinger, Marcy Gentry       

Respondent:

Atty:     

 

1:15 PM

 D-101-CV-2019-03291

 Kevin Abell

  v.

1001 Nights Inc, et. al.

 MOTION HEARING

 Civil Violations, Statutes, Ordinances

 Comment:  Defendant's Motion to Compel Discovery and Impose Sanctions for Failure to Answer and Respond to Discovery  //  Counterclaimant's Motion to Compel Discovery and Impose Sanctions for Failure to Answer and Respond to Discovery

Plaintiff

Abell, Kevin        

Atty: Howell, Trent Atkins        

Defendant

1001 Nights Inc; Seret, Ira; Seret, Sylvia     

Atty: Paisner, S. Barry     

 

11/13/2020

8:00 AM

Judge Francis J. Mathew General Session

 

10:00 AM

 D-101-CV-2019-02322

 Patrick Joseph Serrano

  v.

State of  New Mexico Department of Taxation and Revenue (MVD)

 MERITS HEARING

 License Revocation Appeal - Plaintiff Appellant

 Comment:  [Rescheduled from October 2, 2020.]

Plaintiff

     Serrano, Patrick Joseph   

Atty:        Pro Se 

Defendant

  State of  New Mexico Department of Taxation and Revenue (MVD)   

Atty:   Ryanczak, Regina A.   

 

10:15 AM

 D-101-CV-2020-01329

 Ricardo Bahe

  v.

State of New Mexico

 MERITS HEARING

 License Revocation Appeal - Plaintiff Appellant

 Comment:  [Rescheduled from October 2, 2020.]

Plaintiff

     Bahe, Ricardo   

Atty:         

Defendant

  State of New Mexico   

Atty:   Ryanczak, Regina A.   

 

10:30 AM

 D-101-CV-2020-01660

 JOE R SISNEROS

 v.

STATE OF NEW MEXICO TAXATION

 MERITS HEARING

 Civil Administrative Appeal - Plaintiff Appellant

 Comment:  [Rescheduled from October 2, 2020.]

Plaintiff

     SISNEROS, JOE R   

Atty:        Pro Se 

Defendant

  STATE OF NEW MEXICO TAXATION   

Atty:   Ryanczak, Regina A.   

 

11:00 AM

 D-101-CV-2018-03446

 Kerry Atkinson

  v.

Chevron USA Inc

 SCHEDULING CONFERENCE

 Tort

 Comment:  [SF Non-Jury]

Plaintiff

Atkinson, Kerry        

Atty: Newell, Michael T.         

Defendant

Chevron USA Inc     

Atty:      

 

11:00 AM

 D-101-CV-2019-02324

 In The Matter Of William Magoosh

 SCHEDULING CONFERENCE

 Tort

 Comment:  [SF Jury]

Plaintiff

      Murphy, Dennis Murphy, Dennis 

Atty:         Murphy, Dennis

Defendant

     

Atty:      

 

11:30 AM

 D-101-CV-2020-01481

 In The Matter Of The Name Change of Lee Maida

 NAME CHANGE HEARING

 Name Change

 Comment: 

Plaintiff

       Maida, Lee 

Atty:         

Defendant

     

Atty:      

 

11:30 AM

 D-101-CV-2020-02179

 In The Matter Of The Name Change of Juanita Urioste

 NAME CHANGE HEARING

 Name Change

 Comment: 

Plaintiff

       Urioste, Juanita 

Atty:         

Defendant

     

Atty:      

 

11:30 AM

 D-101-CV-2020-02208

 In The Matter Of The Name Change of Ramona Lueras

 NAME CHANGE HEARING

 Name Change

 Comment: 

Plaintiff

       Lueras, Ramona 

Atty:         

Defendant

     

Atty:      

 

1:15 PM

 D-101-CV-2019-01871

 Discover Bank

  v.

Elizabeth Vannah

 MOTION HEARING

 Contract/Debt & Money Due

 Comment:  Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings

Plaintiff

Discover Bank        

Atty: Guglielmo, Eliza Ann        

Defendant

Vannah, Elizabeth     

Atty:      

 

11/16/2020

8:00 AM

Judge Francis J. Mathew General Session

 

10:00 AM

 D-101-CV-2018-02171

 Peter Wirth, et. al.,

  v.

Cory Thompson, et. al.

 MOTION HEARING

 Tort

 Comment:  Defendants Stephanie Benson, M.D.'s and Diana Escobedo, M.D.'s Motion for Partial Summary Judgment on Plaintiffs' Claim for Punitive Damages  //  Defendant Memorial Medical Center's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment on the Claim of Punitive Damages  // Defendant Kristina Polanco, RN's Motion for Summary Judgment on Plaintiffs' Claims against Kristina Polanco, RN  //  Defendant Memorial Medical Center's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment on Vicarious Liability  //  Defendants Stephanie Benson, M.D.'s and Diana Escobedo, M.D.'s Motion for Summary Judgment Due to Lack of Expert Testimony  //  Defendants Cory Thompson, DMD and Southern New Mexico Dental Group, PC d/b/a Hillrise Dental's Motion for Summary Judgment; Plaintiff's Claim Lack Factual Support  //  Defendants Cory Thompson, DMD and Southern New Mexico Group, PC d/b/a Hillrise Dental's Motion for Summary Judgment on Issue of Punitive Damages  //  Defendants Cory Thompson, DMD and Southern New Mexico Group, PC d/b/a Hillrise Dental's Motion for Summary Judgment on Issue of Punitive Damages

Plaintiff

Blanco, Renee; Valencia, Gilbert; Wirth, Peter        

Atty: Cervantes, K. Joseph        

Defendant

Benson, Stephanie, MD; D M D; Daily, Brenda, RN; Escobedo, Diana, MD; Graham, Xochitl, RN; Las Cruces Physician Practices LLC; Lifepoint Health Inc; Memorial Ear Nose and Throat Institute; Ontiveros, Kristy, MD; Owens, Jonathan, MD; PHC Las Cruces Inc; Polanco, Kristina, RN; Reynolds, Lizabeth, MD; Southern New Mexico Dental Group PC; Thompson, Cory; Wilson, Megan, RN     

Atty: Ali, Nora; Maggiore, W. Ann; Kenny, Rebecca Shaw; Parker, Jennifer Lyn; Smith, Kemp; Mann, John Scott; Rogers, Lee M., Jr.; Cash, Paul M; Miller, Kimberly Ann Norvell     

 

 

 

 

 

11/18/2020

8:00 AM

Judge Francis J. Mathew General Session

 

10:00 AM

 D-101-CV-2018-02171

 Peter Wirth, et. al.,

  v.

Cory Thompson, et. al.

 MOTION HEARING

 Tort

 Comment:  Plaintiffs' Motion for Partial Summary Judgment that Defendant Memorial Medical Center did not Qualify as a Healthcare Provider under the Medical Malpractice Act by Illusory Coverage  //  Plaintiffs' Motion for Partial Summary Judgment that Defendant Jonathan Owens, M.D. did not Qualify as a Healthcare Provider under the Medical Malpractice Act by Illusory Coverage  //  Plaintiffs' Motion for Partial Summary Judgment that Defendant Diana Escobedo, MD. did not Qualify as a Healthcare Provider under the Medical Malpractice Act by Illusory Coverage  // Plaintiffs' Motion for Partial Summary Judgment that Defendant Stephanie Benson, M.D. did not Qualify as a Healthcare Provider under the Medical Malpractice Act by Illusory Coverage //  Plaintiffs' Motion for Continuance, Plaintiffs' Response to LifePoint Renewed Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Personal Jurisdiction  //  Plaintiffs' Rule 56(F) Motion for Continuance and Stay Ruling on LifePoint's Motion for Summary Judgment on All of Plaintiffs' Claims

Plaintiff

Blanco, Renee; Valencia, Gilbert; Wirth, Peter        

Atty: Cervantes, K. Joseph        

Defendant

Benson, Stephanie, MD; D M D; Daily, Brenda, RN; Escobedo, Diana, MD; Graham, Xochitl, RN; Las Cruces Physician Practices LLC; Lifepoint Health Inc; Memorial Ear Nose and Throat Institute; Ontiveros, Kristy, MD; Owens, Jonathan, MD; PHC Las Cruces Inc; Polanco, Kristina, RN; Reynolds, Lizabeth, MD; Southern New Mexico Dental Group PC; Thompson, Cory; Wilson, Megan, RN     

Atty: Ali, Nora; Maggiore, W. Ann; Kenny, Rebecca Shaw; Parker, Jennifer Lyn; Smith, Kemp; Mann, John Scott; Rogers, Lee M., Jr.; Cash, Paul M; Miller, Kimberly Ann Norvell     

 

 

 

 

11/20/2020

8:00 AM

Judge Francis J. Mathew General Session

 

10:00 AM

 D-101-CV-2018-02171

 Peter Wirth, et. al.,

  v.

Cory Thompson, et. al.

 MOTION HEARING

 Tort

 Comment:  Defendants PHC-Las Cruces, Inc. d/b/a Memorial Medical Center, Kristina Polanco, RN, Brenda Dailey, RN, Xochitl Graham, RN and Megan Wilson, RN's Motions in Limine Regarding:  Defendants' Motion in Limine to Exclude Undisclosed Theories of Liability or Causation at Trial  //  Defendants' Motion in Limine to Exclude Plaintiffs' Use of Evidence or Conduct that Appeals to the Sympathies of the Jury, is Inflammatory and/or Prejudicial  //  Defendants' Motion in Limine to Exclude Evidence Alluding to Financial Incentive or Profit Motive of Wealth or or Size of Memorial Medical Center  //  Defendants' Motion in Limine to Preclude Expert Witnesses from Testifying Outside Their Area of Expertise or from Offering New or Undesignated Opinion Testimony  //  Defendants' Motion in Limine to Exclude Impermissible Hypothetical Questions  //   Defendants' Motion in Limine Regarding Punitive Damages Evidence  //  Defendants' Motion in Limine to Exclude any Statements or References Attempting to get the Jury to Invoice the Golden Rule  //  Defendants' Motion in Limine to Preclude Plaintiffs from Making Statements that Memorial Medical Center Directed or Controlled any Provider's Medical Decisions  //  Defendant's Motion in Limine to Preclude Lawyers from Making Statements not Supported by the Factual Record in Opening Statements  //  Defendants' Motion in Limine to Exclude Cumulative Expert Testimony on Standard of Care Causation  //  Defendants' Motion in Limine to Exclude Evidence of Insurance  //  Defendants' Motion in Limine to Exclude Evidence of Other Lawsuits and any other Alleged Bad Acts  //  Defendants' Omnibus Motion in Limine  //  Defendants' Motion in Limine to Exclude Argument Made by Counsel Contrary to Law  //  Defendants' Motion in Limine to Exclude Prior Rulings by this Court  //  LifePoint Health, Inc.’s Motion in Limine  //  Plaintiffs’ Omnibus Motion in Limine

Plaintiff

Blanco, Renee; Valencia, Gilbert; Wirth, Peter        

Atty: Cervantes, K. Joseph        

Defendant

Benson, Stephanie, MD; D M D; Daily, Brenda, RN; Escobedo, Diana, MD; Graham, Xochitl, RN; Las Cruces Physician Practices LLC; Lifepoint Health Inc; Memorial Ear Nose and Throat Institute; Ontiveros, Kristy, MD; Owens, Jonathan, MD; PHC Las Cruces Inc; Polanco, Kristina, RN; Reynolds, Lizabeth, MD; Southern New Mexico Dental Group PC; Thompson, Cory; Wilson, Megan, RN     

Atty: Ali, Nora; Maggiore, W. Ann; Kenny, Rebecca Shaw; Parker, Jennifer Lyn; Smith, Kemp; Mann, John Scott; Rogers, Lee M., Jr.; Cash, Paul M; Miller, Kimberly Ann Norvell